This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Most pitches are won or lost on things that happen long before the final slide. The leaders we have interviewed describe the same sequence, from the research done weeks earlier to the way a process is managed once the mandate is in hand.

In September, I shared five lessons from Oren Klaff on winning the room, and our full episode with him is now on the podcast. This issue takes a different route. Instead of lessons, it follows the meeting in the order it happens: before you arrive, how you open, how you set the terms, the question that closes, and how you manage the process afterwards. Oren is joined by four other leaders along the way.

Before The Meeting: Do The Listening Early

Aaron Schwimmer, Partner at MTS Health Partners, argues that listening is not something you save for the room.

❝

“You need to listen before you even get to the meeting. You should be listening to your client all the time. Companies are always saying something. They’re out talking to investors. They’re doing quarterly calls.”

Aaron Schwimmer, Partner, MTS Health Partners

Simon Mordant, Vice Chairman of Luminis Partners, builds his preparation the same way, and describes it as “a bit like a game of chess.” He reads the company’s market presentations and “what analysts are saying,” and he might even “talk to some investors directly to get a real sense of what they think the issues are.” He also looks at the board for anyone he knows who can help him understand what is keeping the CEO awake at night.

His aim is not to arrive with answers. It is to arrive having already thought about what the client is likely to say.

Before The Meeting: Know What The Meeting is About

Gary Shields, Chairman and Managing Partner of Nassau Street Partners, has pitched from both sides and is candid about his own miss. A company was referred to him with the message that it wanted to talk about an acquisition. He took that to mean the company was buying. In his words, “I walked into the meeting not realising they were interested in talking about selling.” It was a deal of roughly $300 to $400 million, and he says he would have brought his team had he known.

❝

“You must be prepared and research the company, and in today’s world with AI, it takes a couple of keystrokes and all of a sudden you know more about the company than the CEO knows.”

Gary Shields, Chairman and Managing Partner, Nassau Street Partners

His list of what loses mandates is short: not being prepared, “walking in with a weak story” and not having the team together. His own team will sometimes “actually almost script the presentation” so that everything the client cares about is covered. The consequence of skipping this, he says, is that “you get ghosted,” with the client going through the process but not fully engaged. The practical fix is to confirm the purpose of the meeting in writing beforehand.

Before The Meeting: Shrink The Book

Both Aaron and Simon were direct about the pitch book. Aaron said he was taught early on that a long book can get in the way of a relationship.

❝

“Putting a 50-page book in front of them… and then flipping that book over time, I think you’ve got a literal barrier between you and a client in terms of building a relationship.”

Aaron Schwimmer, Partner, MTS Health Partners

His fix is to “create a handful of pages, send it over to the CEO or the client” before the meeting, and then “show up without anything and have a discussion.” Simon takes a similar approach. At most, he says, “I’m going to have one page in writing,” and he does not start the conversation with it on the table. His objection to the 200-page book is that “the banker is sitting in front of the client turning pages and talking. They’re not listening.”

Oren makes the same point from a different angle. The material that proves who you are, your team, track record and capabilities is, in his words, “confirmatory,” and he would keep it for the end.

Opening: Show You Can Structure The Market

When Oren described how he would open a pitch, I expected the message to be about having better information. His story shows it is not. He told us he once gave a presentation on market conditions at a conference. The next day, a banker from a large investment bank presented the same structure, with the firm’s logo on it.

When Oren asked what had happened, the answer was, “It was too good. I just had to copy it.” His conclusion is the part worth taking away.

❝

“We all have the same market information, but the structuring of the information that way is very, very compelling.”

Oren Klaff, author of Pitch Anything and Flip the Script

He also noted that AI has made the research easy. “Now that you have ChatGPT, this is really easy to research.” If everyone can find the same facts, the differentiator is how you arrange them. Oren’s method is to open with what is changing, because “the mind latches on to things that are changing.” We covered that in September, and the new point is that structure is the edge when information is cheap.

Opening: You Have About Sixty Seconds to Build Trust

Gary Shields makes the same point from the other end of the pitch. He thinks about the elevator pitch literally: there is a reason it is short, and the window is shorter than most bankers assume.

❝

“If you don’t gain that trust during that period, then you’re going to lose that client or that prospect.”

He gives the period as 30 seconds, or 60 (“I’ll give you a break”). His test comes from a venture capitalist his friend interviewed: “Would I trust this person babysitting my children?” His tip for building trust fast is to share a personal story. He once coached an executive who thought he had nothing to tell, until it emerged that he was an Eagle Scout. “That’s a powerful story to tell somebody,” Gary told him.

In The Room: Set The Terms

Oren’s view is that most bake-offs put the banker in a low-status position, with the client holding the decision. Before any pitch, he sets a different frame.

❝

“We have to leave at least half the time for us to understand you. We’re very choosy about who we work with.”

Oren Klaff, author of Pitch Anything and Flip the Script

This is not arrogance. It is mutual evaluation. A banker who is also assessing whether the situation is real is easier to take seriously than one who is waiting to be picked. Oren says that when a client sees you as a peer, they are willing to be flexible and understand that “your time, your money, your success is as important as theirs.”

In The Room: Notice Words That Lower Your Status

Oren’s answer to my final question was not what I expected. I asked which communication habit bankers should change immediately, and he pointed at three polite words.

❝

“Please, thank you, and I’m sorry create the condition of you are higher than me.”

He is not arguing for rudeness. He accepts that people make mistakes. What he does when a meeting goes badly is acknowledge it plainly and offer a next step: “Listen, that was not ideal at all. Certainly not our best face. Let’s reschedule and make it happen for real. How’s Tuesday, ten o’clock?” The point is the difference between professionalism and deference. As a Brit, I told him I am guilty of the second, and I suspect I am not alone.

The Close: Ask The Questions You Are Afraid Of

Neno Raic, co-founder and Managing Partner at NLC, spent years raising capital before building his own firm. He told us the most useful habit he learned was asking the question that might get a no.

❝

“Is this product relevant to you? That’s a scary question, ’cause they could say no, and then you know, you failed your pitch.”

Neno Raic, Co-founder and Managing Partner, NLC

The alternative is more comfortable and less useful. In his words, “you can come out of that meeting feeling relatively good about yourself, but you have no idea if that person is interested or not.” Asking early replaces uncertainty with a decision, and it saves time on the back end.

After: Control The Process With Integrity

Once a pitch is won, or nearly won, the process still has to be managed. Oren’s argument is that clients are not experts at it, and that managing it is the banker’s job: “It is your job. The clients are going to raise money or sell their company once in a while.”

❝

“If you don’t control the deal, then they will control it, and they will do it poorly.”

Oren Klaff, author of Pitch Anything and Flip the Script

We covered his waypoint approach to managing timelines in September. The new part from the episode is the warning on what happens without it. “If you don’t have client control, they’re always going to re-trade you.” He is equally clear on the limits of control. It works only with values behind it, and he says plainly that it “requires values and self-regulation.”

Closing Thought

Most bankers prepare for the meeting by building materials. The leaders in this issue prepare by building understanding: listening before they arrive, trimming what they bring, structuring what they know, setting the terms of the room and asking for a clear answer.

The boardroom is rarely won by the biggest book. It is won by the banker who looks most ready to help the client decide.

Leadership Quote of the Week

“Lean in. Your voice matters in the room.”

 Evie Vanezi - EMEA Chief Executive Officer at Jefferies

Recent Podcast Releases

Episode 50: How to Win More Deals Through Psychology, Influence & Persuasion?

What makes a great investment banker stand out when every firm has the same credentials, technical expertise and impressive deal experience?

In this episode, Oren Klaff, author of Pitch Anything, investor and capital markets advisor, joins Peter Nieberg to explore the psychology of winning mandates and influencing senior decision-makers.

We discuss why relationships and momentum matter, how to position yourself as a peer when pitching to CEOs and boards, and how to build credibility through insight rather than relying on credentials alone. Oren also shares practical advice on structuring more effective pitches, managing client expectations and maintaining control throughout a deal.

The conversation explores the balance between influence and manipulation, and how presence, communication and professional confidence can help turn expertise into results.

Episode 49: The Nordic Playbook for Winning in Asia

Winning in investment banking isn’t about chasing every opportunity. It’s about knowing where to focus, which clients to prioritise and how to build a franchise that stands the test of time.

In this episode, Joachim Jaeger Skorge, Managing Director and Head of Asia-Pacific Investment Banking at DNB Carnegie, reflects on nearly three decades in investment banking and the lessons he’s learned from building a cross-border business across Oslo, New York and Singapore.

We explore why trying to win every deal can mean winning none, why smaller transactions can sometimes be harder to close than larger ones, and how strategic focus can create a lasting competitive advantage. Joachim also shares insights into the strengths of Nordic investment banking, the opportunities in Asia-Pacific and what it takes to build a successful franchise from the ground up.

The conversation also examines the importance of trust, adapting across cultures and staying authentic in different markets. Drawing on almost 20 years in Asia, Joachim reflects on leadership, resilience and what it takes to build a long-term career in investment banking.

Read of the Week

“Never Split the Difference” by Chris Voss

A former FBI hostage negotiator explains how to use empathy, listening and carefully chosen questions to influence outcomes.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate