By 2028, most Investment Banking VPs and Directors will fall into one of two categories:

  • Mini-franchise owners

  • Highly trusted execution leaders

There will be less room in the middle.

The challenge?

Almost nobody has given you a serious, insider playbook for origination, especially if you’ve spent 10–12 years being rewarded for flawless execution, not for creating the next mandate .

This newsletter is that playbook.

The Four Problems Nobody Fixes For You

Let’s start with the reality that most VPs and Directors are living.

1.“I Don’t Have Time”

You’re staffed wall-to-wall:

  • Live deals

  • Internal processes

  • Junior management

Origination feels like something you’ll “get to later.” But the market is already shifting. Firms are promoting those who show an early revenue signal:

  • Ideas

  • Relationships

  • Momentum

If you don’t make time for origination, the decision eventually gets made for you.

2.“I Don’t Have The Skill Set”

You were trained to:

  • Execute

  • Control

  • Deliver

Not to:

  • Prospect

  • Start conversations

  • Take a view

  • Create opportunities

Yet that’s exactly what promotion committees now expect.

3.“My MD Is Too Busy To Teach Me”

Most MDs:

  • Learned through experience

  • Don’t have structured coaching frameworks

  • Expect you to figure it out

So you’re left assembling your own playbook.

4.“External Training Doesn’t Translate”

Generic BD and sales training doesn’t reflect your world.

You’re not selling a product. You’re earning the right to advise. Origination in investment banking is not traditional sales.

It’s expertise, credibility, judgment, and timing in a competitive ecosystem.

The Reframe: You Are The Product

One of the most important shifts comes from Matt Dixon’s The Activator Advantage.

In professional services, you are not “selling” something separate. You are the product. That means you are a Doer-Seller:

  • You win the work

  • And you deliver it

The implication is powerful. Origination is not a separate activity. It is an extension of how you show up. And this is where most VPs get stuck.

They still operate like: “I’m an expert who sometimes has to sell.”

The bankers who break through shift to: “I’m a business builder who happens to be an expert.” That mindset change alone can be career-defining.

The Reframe: Execution Is Origination

Most VPs treat execution and origination as separate. The best bankers don’t. They stack them. As Matt Zimmer, Global Head of IB at William Blair on the IB Leaders Podcast recently put it:

“Execution… is the best form of origination.”

Every interaction is building or eroding future revenue. “Every interaction should be considered your last interaction with a client.”

Similarly, Marcel Brix Managing Partner at Blok Management reinforces this:

“You can and should do origination everywhere”

The implication is simple: You are either building your future pipeline or missing it every day.

Discipline: The Real Differentiator

Most bankers don’t fail at origination because they lack ability. They fail because they lack discipline. Execution requires discipline.

Origination requires a different kind:

  • Consistency without immediate reward

  • Effort without guaranteed outcomes

  • Long-term thinking under short-term pressure

Marcel Brix captures it clearly:

“It’s a consistent marathon, not a sprint.”

This is exactly where the Activator model sharpens the point:

Activators don’t find time for origination. They commit to it structurally and treat it as a Non-negotiable.

The Origination Rhythm That Actually Works

You will never “find” time. You have to build it and protect it. As Marcel Brix puts it: “You need to block your calendar with organisation and discipline.”

The best in the industry carve out at least 1-2 hours a week to be intentional about building and cultivating meaningful relationships. They utilize LinkedIn and show up to events, no matter how busy they get.

The Activator Edge: Three Behaviours Key Behaviours

The Activator Advantage breaks origination into three behaviours that map perfectly to Investment banking.

1. Create Demand (Not Just Respond to It)

Most bankers wait:

  • For RFPs

  • For inbound

  • For “live situations”

Activators don’t. They bring commercial insight that creates the opportunity. This aligns directly with your role:

  • Identifying opportunities

  • Connecting dots, clients haven’t

  • Showing what needs to happen in the future.

As Philip Ross, the Chairman Global Healthcare IB at Jefferies put it on the IB Leaders Podcast:

“Look at your relationships in a 10-year arc. Transactions are episodic; a banker’s value lies in being present and providing advice even when there is no immediate transaction on the table.”

He also shared that “Taking a view is what is memorable.”

Not: “What do you want to do?” But: “Here’s what you should be thinking about and why.”

That’s how relationships grow, and mandates start.

2. Build ‘Zippered’ Relationships (Not Fragile Ones)

Most VPs have one strong contact, which is fragile. You need to build a wide breadth of contacts and know multiple stakeholders. You also need to collaborate well and bring the right internal stakeholders to each opportunity.

Matt Zimmer stressed the importance of moving beyond a "solo act" by emphasising a philosophy he calls "Don't Be a Hero". He argues that rising leaders, who are open to collaboration and bring in a Managing Director or other internal stakeholders to establish better credibility, actually "accelerate faster in business"

Origination is not: “My client”. It’s: “Our platform’s relationship.” That’s how you build durability and scale your franchise.

3. Deliver Value Before You’re Paid

Traditional thinking: “Hire us, then we’ll add value.” If you flip this and find ways to show value for potential clients, your relationships grow fast. “We’ll show you value first.” In banking, showing value first looks like:

  • A sharp insight note

  • A useful article

  • A targeted “what if” scenario

  • A short perspective deck

Not a pitch. A perspective.

The Four Origination Capabilities That Matter

When you combine IB reality with the Activator model, origination simplifies into four capabilities:

1. Insight — Take a View

Clients remember conviction, not just information.

2. Access — Build Real Entry Points

Start with relevance, not hierarchy.

3. Momentum — Move Conversations Forward

Ideas don’t win deals. Momentum does.

4. Memory — Play the Long Game

Track, follow up, and compound relationships.

Final Thoughts

Origination is not something you can suddenly switch on at the VP or Director level.

It is built quietly in how you show up on deals, how you think about clients, and how consistently you choose to create opportunity rather than wait for it.

Over time, that behaviour compounds. Reputations are formed, trust builds, and a pattern becomes visible to clients, to colleagues, and ultimately to those making promotion decisions.

The question is not whether you are capable of origination. It is whether you are building it deliberately. Because in today’s market, the difference between those who move forward and those who stall is rarely technical.

It is whether they made the shift early enough from executing work to creating it.

Other Great Resources

Leadership Quote of the Week

"Generating revenue is a skill that you build years in advance of the MD role”

Sher Hafeez- Snr MD at JLL Securities

Podcast Episodes

Episode 40: Most Bankers Fail at the VP - Director Transition (And How to Get It Right)

Why do so many investment bankers struggle to make the jump from execution to origination?

In this episode, Matt Zimmer, Head of Investment Banking at William Blair, shares what it really takes to succeed at the senior level, from building a 700-person global platform to developing the next generation of leaders.

We cover the mindset shift from VP to Director, why perfect execution is the foundation of origination, and how client trust, collaboration, and high standards drive long-term success.

Matt also shares powerful lessons on leadership, culture, and scaling teams. Including why great leaders act as “player-coaches,” eliminate toxicity fast, and build organisations that punch above their weight.

If you want to transition from executor to leader, this episode is essential listening.

Episode 39: From Medical School to Wall Street: How Great Investment Bankers Think Beyond the Deal

What separates transactional bankers from truly trusted advisors?

In this episode, ⁠Philip Ross⁠, Vice Chairman and Chairman of Global Healthcare Investment Banking at ⁠Jefferies,  ⁠shares his unconventional journey from medical school to Wall Street, and the principles that have shaped his 28+ year career.

Philip explains why the best bankers think in 10-year relationship arcs, stay relentlessly client-centric, and hold themselves to exceptionally high standards, even when no deal is on the table.

He also breaks down how VPs and Directors can move beyond execution to become strategic partners that clients trust. A masterclass in leadership, origination, and long-term thinking from one of the industry’s most respected voices.

Episode 38: How to Build an Investment Banking Boutique from Zero, and Why Origination is the Real Power

Most investment bankers are trained to execute. Very few are trained to originate, and that’s why most never make partner or build their own firm.

In this episode, Marcel Brix, Co-Managing Director and shareholder at Blok Management, shares how he went from intern to co-founder of one of Germany’s fastest-growing boutique investment banks and why he now spends 90% of his time on origination.

Read of the Week

‘The Activator Advantage: What Today’s Rainmakers Do Differently’ by Matt Dixon

A road map for any professional services partner or firm leader looking to chart a path to greater client engagement, internal collaboration, and firm profitability in the new era of fading client loyalty.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Keep Reading